Sports Direct shareholders urge fair play as Mike Ashley's games go on

Sports Directs chairman Keith Hellawell shielded himself from reporters with his brown, battered briefcase and fled the companys annual meeting on Thursday. The 75-year-old who once used to make the most of his intimidating broad-shouldered stature seemed to have shrunk from the stress of having his stewardship of the sportswear giant come under fire for the third time in as many years.
Despite once boasting of making a career out of controversy, Hellawell has been wounded by a sustained investor campaign against him which has seen him branded as Mike Ashleys poodle.It didnt used to be like this for the man once known as the black knight, a moniker he was given due to his penchant for dressing entirely in black and driving a black Porsche during his time as a chief constable.
Hellawells autobiography The Outsiderrecalls his troubled childhood as an abused, squint-eyed boy who worked his way up through establishment ranks to make headlines by becoming the countrys youngest police chief, pushing for the legalisation of brothels and drawing confessions out of the Yorkshire Ripper, Peter Sutcliffe. His time as Tony Blairs drug tsar ended in a row over the weakening of marijuanas classification. However, while he has spent the past 40 years in public life, his seven years at Sports Direct have been some of his most uncomfortable.
Sports Direct shareholders urge fair play as Mike Ashley's games go on

Keith Hellawell (right) arriving at Sports Direct's headquarters in Shirebrook
Last week he barely survived another shareholder revolt with 47pc of independent investors voting against his re-election. After two previous rebellions against him, where he was only saved by Ashleys controlling stake, he had promised to step down if the majority of independents rebelled once more. However, this time he clinched support from 53.2pc of independent shareholders. He got away with it, was how one shareholder characterised the narrow vote.
Even after poll results declared that he had escaped a toppling, Hellawell refused to make any comments about his future at Sports Direct. That didnt stop his detractors from questioning whether he was a sufficient check on Ashleys controlling influence at the company.
It is clear that the re-election of Keith Hellawell is far from a ringing endorsement, said Paul Lee, head of corporate governance at Aberdeen Standard Investments. The company hasnt made good on its previous promises and we do not yet have confidence that the chairman and board are holding the chief executive to account in the way that they should.
When Hellawell was asked two years ago whether he could keep the tycoon in check, he said: As a policeman Ive controlled people from serial killers to rapists and Mike Ashley doesnt need controlling. Meanwhile, Ashley, who jokingly calls the former policeman Plod, has said of Hellawell: He knows my strengths, he knows my weaknesses.
Sports Direct shareholders urge fair play as Mike Ashley's games go on

Mike Ashley, inside Sports Direct's warehouse
While Aberdeen Standard Investments, Royal London, Fidelity, Legal & General and Hermes voted against Hellawell, their opposition was diluted by Standard Life, one of his fiercest critics, having sold its 6pc stake in the past year. That margin could have boosted the rebels cause.
The effort to remove Hellawell was also lacking influential support from the Investor Forum the body specifically set up to push recalcitrant companies into better behaviour. The Investor Forum had campaigned vigorously last year for an independent review of the companys entire corporate governance framework. It even added that, if directors were unwilling to implement the review, serious questions will be raised as to whether they truly represent the interests of all shareholders and, therefore, whether they are meeting their statutory director duties.
But since that feisty message there has been deafening silence from the Investor Forum, despite Sports Direct reneging on its promise of an independent review. Despite its initial best efforts, the forum has proved to be just another toothless body.
Mike Ashleys Adventures | Taste for gambling and the high life
Sports Direct claimed an independent review was ditched because of two potentials turning down the chairman post. Instead it hired law firm RPC, which the forum had already publicly said it did not believe was independent due to its long-standing relationship with Sports Direct and Ashley.
Last week Hellawell said that the corporate governance review was ongoing and had raised five areas of concern, without detailing what they were. This was hardly the very open ethos that Sports Direct had promised in its 2016 presentation to investors.
Last year Sports Direct threw the doors open to its annual meeting and took the unusual step of employing Eventbrite, a ticketing company normally employed by music festivals, to encourage droves of interested pundits to make the trip to Shirebrook.
Sports Direct shareholders urge fair play as Mike Ashley's games go on

Mike Ashley produces wad of ?50 notes at Sports Direct security
As well as a tour around the vast Shirebrook warehouse led by Ashley, the company issued a bold presentation that promised time for change.
It was an explicit effort to draw a line under a scandal-ridden period. This year, there were fewer than 15 investors in attendance, no open day and no Ashley.
The trainers and tracksuits tycoon said he had other business commitments that meant he couldnt attend the once-a-year event with the fellow owners of the company.
Hes given up withoutsiders, says Crispin Odey, a hedge fund manager with a 3pc stake in Sports Direct and one-time supporter of Ashley. The only other company thats like this is Ryanair, adds Odey, pointing out the similarity between Ashley and the publicity magnet Michael OLeary.
Sports Direct share price
However, some investors defiantly believe that Ashley and Sports Directs ongoing apathy for corporate governance box-ticking is part of the reason for its success. Mike Ashley is aligned with shareholders by the virtue of owning more shares than anyone else, says Tristan Chapple, director of Phoenix Asset Management, which holds a 3.5pc stake in the business.
He has an outstanding track record in business over the past 25 years. A lot of what he has done, despite at times appearing unconventional, has helped to grow the business. Although we monitor their progress very closely, we dont waste time second-guessing his individual decisions.
Sports Directs board had given its blessing to Ashleys AGM absence by reasoning that there had been a detailed question and answer session with analysts and investors at the companys full-year results meeting inJuly.
At the results, which included a 60pc crash in profits, Ashley released just one punchy PowerPoint slide bearing the words: Its clear that we have smashed the ball out of the park with our Selfridges of sport concept.
Sports Direct shareholders urge fair play as Mike Ashley's games go on

Sports Direct has been opening new stores to improve its image with sports brands Nike and Adidas
The Selfridges of sport analogy at first provoked titters from industry experts who highlighted the gulf between Sports Directs cluttered pile it high, sell it cheap shops and the grandiose department store. However, Ashley is aware that he needs to rapidly elevate Sports Directs customers and products after missing out on the booming athleisurewear trend.
The company splashed out more than ?300m last year on property as part of its strategy to improve relationships with brands like Nike and adidas. Sports Direct now has 25 new generation stores, of which 13 are deemed to be flagship worthy. Ashley reckons this number can grow to between 75 and 160 over the next five to 10 years.
Sports Direct shareholders urge fair play as Mike Ashley's games go on

Selfridges department store on Oxford Street
However, while the 25 new generation stores have been beating expectations, they are in the minority as Sports Directs retail estate of 232 shops continues to be littered with tired, old stores. The job is still very far from done but the early signs from Sports Directs flagship stores are visually very positive, says Jonathan Pritchard, an analyst at Peel Hunt.
However, for Pritchard the key test will be whether Sports Direct can convince quality branded products [to return to] the non-flagship stores, and that will take a while to re-emerge as Sports Direct has yet to be fully allowed off the manufacturers naughty step. Ashleys attempt to turn Sports Direct into Selfridges has also been the driving force behind his scattergun acquisition spree.
The tycoon has used various means to acquire upmarket lingerie firm Agent Provocateur, and stakes in French Connection, Game Digital, Debenhams, Goals Soccer, and US retailers Finish Line and Dicks Sporting Goods. However, recent efforts to take full ownership of designer retail chain Flannels are the most explicit demonstration of his ambition to move upmarket.
Sports Direct shareholders urge fair play as Mike Ashley's games go on

Matilda Ashley's make-up range SportFX was launched last year with the help of reality-TV celebrities, such as Made in Chelsea's Louise Thompson
His daughter Matildas make-up business, SportFX, is already stocked in Sports Direct shops but could be rolled out across Flannels shops in an attempt to recreate Selfridges renowned beautyhalls.
After all, Ashley knows that the best way to silence dissenting investors is to turn sales and profits around.
Embed code: How to connect with us | Telegraph Business on social media
See also:
Leave a comment
  • Latest
  • Read
  • Commented
Calendar Content
«     2017    »