Labour adopts antisemitism change with free-speech clause

By Aubrey Allegretti, political reporter
Labour has fully adopted the international definition and examples of antisemitism – but added its own “free speech" clause.
Members of the party's National Executive Committee backed a change in its code of conduct to adopt all the provisions included by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA).
They will be used to investigate, suspend and expel members accused of discrimination against Jewish people.The vote marks a crucial moment in a row that has dominated Labour all summer, pitting MPs against each other and seen serious allegations levelled at Jeremy Corbyn.:: Danny DeVito defends Corbyn over antisemitism

[img]" alt="Labour's antisemitism announcement not what it seems" class="sdc-article-strapline__image">
Labour's antisemitism announcement not what it seems
As the party adds a "clarification" on criticising Israel, the issue is still far from over, says Sky's Jon Craig

A spokesperson said the NEC had adopted "all of the IHRA examples of antisemitism, in addition to the IHRA definition which Labour adopted in 2016".They added a statement had been passed too "which ensures this will not in any way undermine freedom of expression on Israel or the rights of Palestinians".Mr Corbyn had proposed his own statement, which said it was not antisemitic to describe "Israel, its policies or the circumstances around its foundation as racist because of their discriminatory impact, or to support another settlement of the Israel-Palestine conflict".The sentence was later withdrawn, with a source telling Sky News: "Team JC climbed down completely. The statement he proposed got completely scrapped."
Some Corbyn supporters held signs calling for the NEC to not be 'bullied' by the IHRA
Dame Margaret Hodge called it "one step forward, two steps backward" and asked why the Labour leader tried to add an "unnecessary qualification".Board of Deputies president Marie van der Zyl welcomed Labour passing the definition and examples as the "right call" but said it was "very long overdue".She added adopting the definition was only the beginning."We need to see firm action taken against antisemites and those who bring the party in to disrepute by denying the problem of antisemitism," she said."Labour must resolve the outstanding cases; introduce greater transparency to the disciplinary process; tackle the culture of the problem of antisemitism and introduce education and training."In addition, Jeremy Corbyn needs to apologise for past antisemitic comments and affiliations."
Labour adopts antisemitism change with free-speech clause

Margaret Hodge called Mr Corbyn's statement 'two steps forward, one step back'
Labour Friends of Israel (LFI) was one of the groups to condemn the freedom of expression clause.Its director, Jennifer Gerber, said it was "unnecessary and totally undermines the other examples the party has supposedly just adopted".Labour Against Antisemitism said the move "appears to be about protecting the freedom of racists to present vile views".Conservative Party chairman Brandon Lewis claimed that adding "caveats" to the definition "exposes Jeremy Corbyn's continued unwillingness to take a firm stand against anti-Jewish racism".
Labour adopts antisemitism change with free-speech clause

Brandon Lewis attacked Mr Corbyn's 'unwillingness' to tackle antisemitism
But Baroness Chakrabarti, Labour's shadow attorney general and the author of a 2016 report on antisemitism, said the statement was "only an exposition of the IHRA definition and examples themselves".She said: "There are great supporters of the Israeli state, there are leading Jewish commentators who have been trying to say to us as a Labour party for months that you can except this definition and all of its examples and still be a vociferous critic of Israel.
"Jeremy was just making that reassurance around the table."
Labour adopts antisemitism change with free-speech clause

Baroness Chakrabarti said the Labour leader was offering 'reassurance'
The long-running row over antisemitism has seen backbencher Frank Field resign the whip, fellow senior MP Margaret Hodge threaten legal action and former chief rabbi Lord Sacks compare the Labour leader to Enoch Powell.The dispute centred over calls for Labour to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's (IHRA) examples of antisemitism in full.The party had already incorporated the IHRA definition, which says: "Antisemitism is a certain perception of Jews, which may be expressed as hatred toward Jews."Rhetorical and physical manifestations of antisemitism are directed toward Jewish or non-Jewish individuals and/or their property, toward Jewish community institutions and religious facilities."Labour also included seven of the IHRA's 11 definitions of antisemitism.
Labour adopts antisemitism change with free-speech clause

A group of Jewish activists protested outside the NEC meeting
However, the party reworded one saying that denying Jewish people the right to self-determination was antisemitic.It also described behaviour in two other definitions - accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel and applying double standards for condemnations of other Jewish people or institutions - as "wrong".And it told Labour members to "resist the use of Hitler, Nazi and Holocaust metaphors, distortions and comparisons".Critics argued it was not as strong as the IHRA examples.The decision on Tuesday was to adopt the IHRA definition and examples unedited and in full - and to add the statement protecting freedom of expression.
Labour adopts antisemitism change with free-speech clause

Mr Corbyn pictured arriving at the NEC meeting in London on Tuesday
Labour sources at the meeting said Mr Corbyn had spoken to the NEC about "eradicating the social cancer of antisemitism".He said the adoption of the full IHRA text and examples was part of the process of "rebuilding trust and as an act of solidarity with Jewish communities".But Mr Corbyn said clarifications were needed to ensure the rights of Palestinians or their supporters were not undermined.Protesters on both sides demonstrated outside Labour's headquarters ahead of the vote.A group draped in Israeli flags held a sign that read: "Corbyn/Milne [his head of communications]... off our lawn! What offends Jews is our business - not yours!"Elsewhere, people were seen holding Momentum banners and a placard that read "it's the Palestinians who are suffering" - with one man dressed in a witch's hat.
More from Jeremy Corbyn

Labour MPs overwhelmingly vote in favour of IHRA antisemitism definition

Danny DeVito defends Jeremy Corbyn amid Labour antisemitism row

Labour's antisemitism announcement not what it seems

Antisemitism: Protests as Labour vote on definition looms

Jeremy Corbyn 'sorry' but 'doesn't see why' Frank Field resigned Labour whip

Brown: Antisemitism rules 'stain must be removed'

The decision to add a "free-speech clause" will also anger many Labour MPs, many of whom were already alarmed by the re-election to the NEC of Peter Willsman.Mr Willsman was caught on tape in July claiming that Jewish "Trump fanatics" were making up antisemitism allegations.
See also:
Leave a comment
  • Latest
  • Read
  • Commented
Calendar Content
«    Июль 2019    »