Authorization

Prime Minister's Questions: The key bits and the verdict

https://ichef-1.bbci.co.uk/news/320/cpsprodpb/1CA3/production/_100313370_acompo.jpg" width="976" height="549">
Theresa May went head-to-head with Jeremy Corbyn in the House of Commons. Here's what happened. The Labour leader went for a double-header this week - starting with a call to end arms sales to Saudi Arabia before switching, rather abruptly, to an attack on the government's "shameful" record on rough sleeping. But the exchanges got off to an unusual start with the PM accusing Mr Corbyn of "mansplaining", after he reminded her that tomorrow was International Women's Day. Mrs May, a self-declared feminist, gave him a hard stare that would make Paddington blush.
Skip Twitter post by @daily_politics
“As she makes her arms sales pitch, will she also call on the crown prince to halt the shocking abuse of human rights in Saudi ArabiaReport
End of Twitter post by @daily_politics
The visit of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman to the UK gave the Labour leader a chance to get stuck into one of his longstanding concerns - human rights abuses in Saudi Arabia. Would the PM be raising them "when she makes her arms sales pitch" to Saudi leader? Mrs May gave a robust defence of the UK's "historic and important" links with Saudi Arabia, which she claimed had saved "hundreds" of lives in the UK through counter-terrorism co-operation, but added: "I will raise human rights concerns with the Crown Prince when I meet him later."Mr Corbyn accused the government of "suppressing" a report into the funding of extremism in the UK - and called for the suspension of UK arms sales to Saudi Arabia, highlighting the "humanitarian disaster" in Yemen he said had been caused by "Saudi-led bombing and a blockade". He called for an urgent ceasefire and even accused the UK government of "colluding with war crimes".
Skip Twitter post 2 by @daily_politics
“600,000 children have cholera because of the Saudi-led bombing campaign” @jeremycorbyn calling for PM to demand “immediate ceasefire in Yemen”

“We are all concerned about the appalling humanitarian situation in Yemen and the effect it is having on people” @theresa_may#PMQs pic.twitter.com/VhI31S1213— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 2 by @daily_politics
The extremism funding report had not been published because of "personal content", said the PM, but senior MPs on the Privy Council could take a look at it. As for Yemen it was down to "all parties" in the conflict to "ensure humanitarian aid got through". Mr Corbyn continued to press for an "urgent ceasefire" in Yemen - and then switched to a question about why rough sleeping had "doubled" under the Conservatives. It wrong-footed Mrs May, who had quite a bit more to say about arms exports to Saudi Arabia, including some quotes from Shadow Foreign Secretary Emily Thornberry, who, she seemed to be suggesting, had supported her position in an interview with the Today programme this morning. As for rough sleeping, the government was pouring "millions" into the problem, she claimed.
Skip Twitter post 3 by @daily_politics
“Why does PM think that rough sleeping fell under Labour but has doubled under the Conservatives” @jeremycorbyn

PM: “This is a government that is putting millions of pounds extra into dealing with rough sleeping, why we are piloting Housing First approach in three major cities" pic.twitter.com/seDts0evrR— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 3 by @daily_politics
There was a small moment of triumph for Mrs May as Mr Corbyn told her that a rough sleeping task force set up 2010 had never met. "It met today," she informed the Labour leader with a smile. The Labour leader continued, accusing the government of lacking ambition in the face of a "crisis" that was "a mark of national shame", throwing in a quote from Barry, who volunteers at a homeless shelter in Southampton, who, like him, believed government cuts were to blame.Mrs May said it wasn't just about money or holding meetings - the government was running "48 projects" to tackle rough sleeping - before rounding off with a quote from Mr Corbyn who had once apparently said Labour's policies on homelessness had caused "misery and despair".
Skip Twitter post 4 by @daily_politics
“The growing number of people on our streets is a mark of national shame” @jeremycorbyn

Record of last Labour gov't "described as in crisis and bringing misery and despair” @theresa_may quoting Mr Corbyn, adding: “He said Labour did not have a good record on housing - I agree” pic.twitter.com/N1KTAoYgUb— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 4 by @daily_politics
What else came up?
Iain Blackford surely deserves some kind of medal for sheer bloody-mindedness. The SNP's leader at Westminster raised the issue of Royal Bank of Scotland for the fourth time at PMQs, only to receive exactly the same reply from Mrs May - it was a "commercial decision" by the bank.
Skip Twitter post 5 by @daily_politics
SNP's @IanBlackfordMP asks PM if she will join him to call on RBS “to encourage people to open accounts to make sure these branches are "sustainable"

But @theresa_may says it was a "commercial matter for the Royal Bank of Scotland" and "up to customers" to make banking decision pic.twitter.com/pWH55GLS1R— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 5 by @daily_politics
Speaker John Bercow was on form, issuing a bizarre-sounding rebuke to a Labour MP.
Skip Twitter post 6 by @daily_politics
The Speaker tells @tobyperkinsmp that his “curious gesticulations” made him look “even odder than….” but appears to stop-sentence.

John Bercow added he was “concerned about your wellbeing” after the MP made references to crochet and tennis #pmqs pic.twitter.com/gD6qBHO86N— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 6 by @daily_politics
The PM got a supportive question on Saudi Arabia from Aldershot Conservative MP Leo Docherty.
Skip Twitter post 7 by @daily_politics
“In fact, the kingdom is a force for tremendous stability in a very turbulent region” says @LeoDochertyUK ahead of PM meeting Saudi crown prince on Wednesday@theresa_may say it “is reforming, is changing, is giving greater rights to women – we should encourage that” #pmqs pic.twitter.com/UXmTuVi176— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 7 by @daily_politics
The Verdicts
Here's what the BBC's Andrew Neil and Laura Kuenssberg made of it:
Skip Twitter post 8 by @daily_politics
“She accused him of mansplaining, it’s become a popular word in recent months” says @afneil looking back on the exchanges and highlights at #pmqs where Saudi Arabia and homelessness dominated #bbcdp pic.twitter.com/XNjYF8oeF4— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 8 by @daily_politics
Skip Twitter post 9 by @daily_politics
“Jeremy Corbyn’s very strong accusations about the British involvement in Yemen: He actually said we were somehow colluding with war crimes…” @bbclaurak before looking at PM reaction: “She did not directly engage with those comments – she did not take it on all.”#pmqs #bbcdp pic.twitter.com/SeS4G0YS7o— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post 9 by @daily_politics
And here is BBC Parliamentary Correspondent Mark D'Arcy's take on it:Maybe it's the lack Tory of blowback from her big Brexit speech last week, but whatever the reason, Theresa May seemed more confident and less careworn at the dispatch box, today. And maybe Jeremy Corbyn's line of attack was just too predictable….The International Women's Day line about the PM raising women's rights issues between pitching for arms sales with the visiting Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia was effective, but was trumped by her "mansplaining" riposte. It clearly delighted her backbenchers, and whether it was pre-prepared or an ad lib, it set the tone for the remainder of her exchanges with the Labour Leader.Nor will Mr Corbyn have enjoyed being countered with quotes from his own shadow foreign secretary and close-ish ally, Emily Thornberry, when the subject moved on to the wider UK relationship with Saudi Arabia. In fact, several moments in this PMQs highlighted the efficiency and effectiveness of her behind the scenes preparation for these appearances. Another example was the PM's answer to York Labour MP Rachael Maskell. She parried a question about rising homelessness in York with a rebuke to the local council, saying it had failed to produce a local plan which would allocate land for more housing. So gold stars to the Downing St PPSs, Seema Kennedy and George Hollingbery, and the team behind them.Mr Corbyn's best moment came when he asked about rising homelessness - but he did not score heavily in the ensuing policy joust. Nor did the SNP Leader Ian Blackford, when he raised branch closures by the state-owned RBS, for the third week running. This produced a patient, even weary, explanation that ministers did not second guess commercial decisions. When backbenchers got their chance - in a 48 minute PMQs today, more than half the time was absorbed by the front bench exchanges - there was an example of an increasingly important function this occasion. Increasingly select committee chairs have realised they can enlist government support for their activities - the question from the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee chairman Neil Parrish, about the concerns raised by the big joint inquiry into air quality won a sympathetic response from Theresa May.This was a more sure-footed prime minister; but it is too soon to suggest her points victory in this particular bout portends a more lasting ascendency. PMQs remains a contents between two, at best, middling parliamentarians.
What pundits are saying on Twitter
Skip Twitter post by @tnewtondunn
“British military advisers are directing the war,” claims Jeremy Corbyn on Yemen. This is pretty close to a direct libel on UK military personnel, and an astounding comment for a wannabe PM #PMQs— Tom Newton Dunn (@tnewtondunn) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post by @tnewtondunn
Skip Twitter post by @Kevin_Maguire
Decency dying in Parliament as May defends her red carpet treatment for the Saudi war leader and head chopper. Ignored Corbyn’s arms sales suspension call #PMQs— Kevin Maguire (@Kevin_Maguire) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post by @Kevin_Maguire
Skip Twitter post by @jamesorharry
Lol at Theresa May’s #pmqs answer that the homelessness taskforce has actually met ‘this morning’. Literally the same as me frantically shoving dirty clothes under the bed when I realise my mum is popping round— James Davies (@jamesorharry) March 7, 2018
Report
End of Twitter post by @jamesorharry
Prime Minister's Questions
See also:
Leave a comment
News
  • Latest
  • Read
  • Commented
Calendar Content
«    Декабрь 2018    »
ПнВтСрЧтПтСбВс
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31