Authorization

Alesha MacPhail murder: Judge lifts ban on naming killer Aaron Campbell

Alesha MacPhail murder: Judge lifts ban on naming killer Aaron Campbell

Aaron Campbell is facing a life sentence
The identity of the teenage boy who raped and murdered six-year-old Alesha MacPhail has been revealed.The judge who presided over the trial has lifted a ban on naming 16-year-old Aaron Campbell.Media outlets, including the BBC, made a case for reversing the court order which had protected his identity because he was under the age of 18.Judge Lord Matthews said: "I can't think of a case in recent times that has attracted such revulsion."After hearing the legal arguments on Friday, he said: "I intend to grant the application. The press may name the accused and publish images of him."
Boy, 16, guilty of Alesha rape and murder
The killer caught by his mother's CCTV
The little girl with the 'big beautiful smile'
Campbell is facing a life sentence after being found guilty of killing Alesha, who went missing while on a visit to her grandparents on the Isle of Bute on 2 July last year.On Thursday, Lord Matthews said he had committed some of the "wickedest, most evil crimes this court has ever heard".
Alesha MacPhail had been on a holiday on the Isle of Bute
Campbell took Alesha from the bed where she was sleeping and inflicted "catastrophic" injuries before dumping her naked body in woodland.Alesha had suffered 117 injuries and died from significant pressure being applied to her face and neck.On Friday, Tony Graham QC, the lawyer representing several news organisations, told the High Court in Glasgow that it would be "naive" to think the teenager's identity was not already known among members of the Bute community and at Polmont Young Offenders Institute.
'Tit-for-tat'
He said the name of the boy had been on Facebook and Twitter, and had been available via a Google search since last July.The QC said the attempt to have the restriction lifted was a balancing act of the age, vulnerability and rights of the murderer, and the potential collateral damage to his family, against the public interest due to the nature of his crimes and the nature of his defence.That defence included a failed attempt to incriminate Toni McLachlan, the 19-year-old teenage girlfriend of Alesha McPhail's father, for the crimes.Brian McConnachie QC, representing Campbell, said the fact that Campbell had incriminated another person was no reason to identify him.He said: "To make an order on the basis that Toni Louise McLachlan was incriminated would simply be tit-for-tat and nothing more than that."
Aaron Campbell has been named as Alesha MacPhail's killer
He also argued that the existence of information on social media was not a reason to overrule the prohibition.He added: "It's little argument to say, well, it's going to happen [his identification] when he's 18 anyway."Mr McConnachie also told Lord Matthews that his client had been warned there was a "price on his head" and that publishing his name could exacerbate the situation as it would increase the number of people aware of his identity.He said: "It is also important to identify at this stage that there is a history, so far as the accused is concerned, of self harm."He said Campbell had a history of anxiety and depression and he had been previously tested for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.
Alesha's body was found in the grounds of a former hotel
Media law lecturer Frank Shennan had earlier told BBC's Good Morning Scotland programme there had been a sense of anger at the killer being "protected".He said: "The reason for not naming under-18s is to protect what is seen as vulnerable people."And the reason for applying to have the ban lifted is a sense of outrage that somebody should be able to hide behind this protection when they have been found guilty of committing such a shocking crime."Ironically until three years ago, we could have named him because the rule applied to under 16s only and it was changed."On Thursday a jury at the High Court in Glasgow took three hours to find Campbell guilty unanimously, following a nine-day trial.He showed no emotion as the verdict was read out.Prosecutor Iain McSporran QC, told the court the loss of a child would be hard to bear in any circumstance, but the "bestial manner" in which Alesha was murdered was "simply unfathomable".
Rothesay
Alesha MacPhail murder trial
Isle of Bute
Airdrie
See also:
Leave a comment
News
  • Latest
  • Read
  • Commented
Calendar Content
«    Август 2019    »
ПнВтСрЧтПтСбВс
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031